Newsletter, Page 2
How to Navigate an Internal Investigation
TEN QUESTIONS TO GUIDE YOUR COURSE, continued
Holly Louie, CHBME, is corporate compliance office for Practice Management Inc.
* Can you be completely objective?
* Is there legal or financial risk to the organization?
* Do you need attorney-client privilege?
3. Should you engage a knowledgeable healthcare attorney?
Spend time thinking this question through from an end result, rather than from an upfront cost perspective. Do you want or need the investigation to be protected? Handling an investigation without legal counsel can cause possible complications, such as additional risk and/or flawed findings due to a lack of expertise in the correct and accurate documentation of the investigation. Give due consideration to the benefits of counsel, not just the cost.
4. What should you document?
The answer is everything. Document every step of the investigation: who, what, when, where, and why. Once you’ve determined there is a credible issue and started an investigation, you have to complete the process by addressing the following operational questions.
* Who found the problem and how?
* What are the details of your investigation?
* Who was interviewed and how were they selected?
What actions did you take and why? Did you educate? Did you write new or revised policies and procedures? What auditing and monitoring did you institute? What corrective actions did you take?
5. Who should conduct the investigation?
The answer to this will vary depending on your organization, expertise, attorney involvement, and who is involved in the allegation. Possible answers include a Knowledgeable compliance officer or owner, designated employees under the compliance officer’s direction, and independent persons under an attorney’s direction. Typically independent persons are used in cases where criminal activity is suspected or where high-level company involvement is suspected; internal investigations are not recommended for these scenarios.
6. How should you proceed once the decision to investigate has been made?
Stop the bleeding!!! As soon as you know there is a credible problem, stop the claims or processes that create additional risk. Then follow these steps:
* Develop a detailed plan of action and stick to it
* Protect all relevant information
* Spell out duties, responsibilities, deliverables, and timelines
* Control the information, details, and processes.
* Make determinations regarding the need for self-disclosure and reassess the involvement of legal counsel. What are the dollars involved? Is a simple repayment adequate resolution?
7. What documentation is relevant?
Once you begin an investigation, you have plunged into the World of Documents. You need to gather them all and step away from the shredder. Define the population. Do you need a statistically valid sample? Will this be a self-disclosure to the government? If so, you probably need counsel and an accounting expert familiar with government sampling requirements.
Consider all of the documentation relevant to the problem. This includes paper documents, electronic files, e-mail, archived data, employee “cheat sheets,” relevant education, policies, procedures, auditing and monitoring findings, etc. Stop the normal course of business-document destruction. Document any records that were destroyed before the start of the investigation and provide the schedule that shows this destruction was part of your normal course of business.
8. How should you conduct yourself during on ongoing investigation?
First, assume everything will be seen by someone else at some time. Maintain professionalism and avoid subjective statements. Don’t try to pay games, In the words of Mayflower Madame Sydney Biddle Barrows, “Never say anything on the phone that you wouldn’t want your mother to hear at the trial.”
9. How should the investigation be reported?
The report may be oral or written, depending upon how the investigation was conducted and by whom. Reports should include an objective analysis of the findings, recommendations, corrective-action details and timelines, auditing, monitoring and repayment schedules.
10. Whom should you tell about the investigation?
This will vary depending on the findings, but basically only those who have a need to know should be given the details. Most investigations are result of system failures, innocent mistakes, or lack of education, not criminal enterprises. When an investigation is necessary do it immediately and thoroughly. In the meantime, build effective prevention and safeguards to protect your company.
WPS—Medicare Provider Outreach and Education
Ellen Berra and Mary Muchow Senior Analysts